rm-ital04winewrong2mr

I was recently asked by the folks at the Food Republic website to toss in a few thoughts on common mistakes I have seen and read about concerning food and wine pairings. I’m grateful for the chance to get my ideas in front of people, but as they asked a lot of other people the same question, they could include a portion of my responses. 

I thought my readers might like to read my more extensive answers, which are equally applicable to pairing with wine, beer or any other kind of beverage. 

1. Missing the point 

Sometimes it’s easy to forget what pairing is about, which is getting people to engage with food and drink in new ways. It’s more than finding a couple of touch-points and declaring it a success. 

Actually, I think “pairing” is the wrong word. The Brazilians have a much better one: harmonizacão (harmonization). To do that, we want to put things together that enhance one another, tell stories and create thrilling new flavors. It’s a romance, not an equation. 

2. Letting one partner overwhelm the other

Because this is so basic, this problem isn’t all that common, but it’s still something to consider. Pairings don’t need to be perfectly balanced; just be sure one half of the pair is not stomping all over the other.

Intensity is hard to define precisely, but easy to assess—you know it when you taste it. Be alert to the fact that it’s not always about the protein. Blackened Creole redfish, with all that spice, can have more impact than a steak. Alcohol content, acidity, bitterness, sweetness, fat, seasonings, cooking methods, sauces, sides, and yes, protein, all contribute. If you have flexibility with the chef when planning, these attributes can offer endless opportunities for tweaking, too.

3. Thinking of a pairing as either contrasting or complimentary

It’s almost always both. So much going on in your mouth that it’s never a zero sum game. Some elements contrast; others blend together harmoniously. Some mask, balance, synergistically enhance or combine to create some surprising new flavor. It’s important to consider all these possibilities.

4. Failing to consider taste/mouthfeel separately from smell

The dynamics of taste, mouthfeel and smell are wildly different from one other. Aromas may be where the magic is, but taste and mouthfeel elements really form the structure of any pairing. Like a bad bridge, a tasting can collapse if its foundation is weak.

Tastes and mouthfeel sensations remain distinct and don’t blend together, but they do impact one another. Science has documented how sweet, salt, acid, fat, bitterness, pepper/chile heat, alcohol and astringency/tannins all interact in specific ways. These are at the heart of any pairing. 

Stronger flavors and mouthfeel sensations often need counterbalancing. One of the most important interactions in wine pairing occurs between fat and polyphenols, including tannins. These grab onto fat molecules, minimizing the impact of both fat and astringency—red wine and steak, anyone? Bitterness in beer can have the same effect, and there are polyphenols there, too.

Fat also strongly adheres to the fat-friendly mucus membranes of the mouth, potentially interfering with access to taste buds by other tastes. This may explain the old adage that if you’re trying to sell a sub-par wine offer it up with some cheese. This will reduce any harshness present in the wine—and would also suggest pairing wine and cheese is not as great as people in the art galleries seem to think.

The heat from chemicals in chiles, black pepper and mustard (capsicum, piperine and allyl isothiocyanate, respectively) are greatly magnified by alcohol level in wine, which is why spicy food is close to impossible to pair with wine, especially reds. Hop bitterness has a similar accelerating effect. 

One important neural phenomenon to keep in mind for pairing is the “contrast effect.”  Visually, a gray shape on a red background will appear greenish, while the same gray on a green background will appear reddish, and the same thing happens with food and drink. Since the brain perceives relatively, not absolutely, a wine with modest sweetness, when put with a sweet dessert, will feel much less sweet and quite a bit more sour. This is why there’s a general rule that a wine should always be sweeter than the food you pair it with. It has also been shown that a little salt can enhance sweetness, but only to a point. Sometimes, like cancels like, as is the case with sweet wines and desserts—at some point our taste buds reach a saturation point and the tastes play to a draw, and simply can’t get any stronger.

The science says that umami taste is barely able to function on its own. It really needs some savory character alongside it to make it come alive: meat or vegetable, and it seems cooked flavors do the same. Umami’s interactions with wine would tend to be a little conjectural, as least as far as the science goes. 

A common maxim of pairing is that “acidity cuts fat.” This does feel true, although I found nothing in the literature that would explain it. Science is really expensive and scientists and funders are drawn to subjects that have value for the big picture. Food and drink pairings are way down the list. Most of the things I’ve come across showing specific interactions have been from work studying the sensory receptors themselves or various aspects of the brain. 

5. When considering aromas, focusing only on shared ones

Unlike our meager range of tastes, smell offers virtually unlimited possibilities for connecting points and harmonies. Aromas, though, behave really differently than tastes or mouthfeel, often blending thoroughly into some new, different odor. 

It’s common to see wine pairings based on shared molecules or similar odors. Whole books (The Flavor Matrix) have been written on the topic, but it’s neither easy nor always successful. Wine has certain aromatic qualities: various types of fruity, floral, citrusy, tropical, grassy and more, but it’s a limited set compared to the aromatic vastness of food. Beer adds a lot more terpenoids, plus the vast range of cooked flavors, which are obviously useful. Sure, there are opportunities for connections based on similarities, but it’s not the only way. 

Odor characters can be used differently. Our lived experience has created in each of us many pleasing flavor combinations. Why not use the food and wine in a way that each provides half of the combined “familiarity” pair? The results are often fun and memorable for your guests. The most famous example is pairing a fruity young red (think Beaujolais) with a fresh chèvre. The result is a berry cheesecake experience. but could you put a mild artisanal cheddar with a fresh apple-ish wine like a Chenin Blanc and get a slice of apple pie?

6. Terroir-based pairings are not no-brainers

There’s a pairing principle that says “what grows together, goes together.” The stories may be great, but it’s folly to assume everything in any cultural or geographic pocket works with everything else there, given the huge range of flavors possible even in the simplest of cuisines (are there really any simple cuisines?). So, no matter what, the basics always apply. That said, traditional pairings in specific regions are worth considering, as they have evolved to taste fantastic together. It’s best to use this a guiding principle while paying attention to the common sense specifics of what’s actually happening in our mouths. Otherwise, you may invite a train wreck to your dinner party.

7. Thinking wine can do everything

Let’s be realistic about wine. It can pair deliciously with some dishes, but people generally give up on salads (too sour), desserts (too sweet except for very specialized dessert wines) and spicy dishes (see #4, above). I don’t know if the common trope about “no wine pairs with asparagus” is true, but vegetables certainly can be challenging. 

Compared to the vast panoply of all possible food flavors, wine overlaps with less than half of them. This means when seeking to find shared odors in food and wine, our toolbox is a lot smaller than we’d like it to be. This is one big advantage beer has over wine as a pairing partner: its huge range of possible cooked (Maillard) and terpenoids from hops extend the landscape considerably.

If you look just at the aroma types present, you’ll find plenty of esters, either of the fresh’n’fruity type in whites and lighter reds, or vinous/”bouquet” types in aged reds. 

There are sometimes “sweet” spiciness (vanilla, cinnamon), sometimes a bit of grassy “green” notes and/or thiol (grapefruit, passion fruit, catty/box-tree), perhaps a splash of butter from too-enthusiastic malolactic fermentation. Several unique varietal aromas come from chemicals that are not esters: fresh, green herbal note in Verdicchio and Lugana: methyl salicylate (wintergreen) and beta damascenone (applesauce, raisins) in V. Labrusca and beta ionone, which imparts its luscious violet character to Nebbiolo.

Aromatic grapes like Moscato and Gewurztraminer aren’t as popular as mainline white varietals, but they’re bursting with floral and citrusy terpenoids that can be useful in food pairing. They’re generally lower in alcohol, too—one more reason they are some of the few wines that actually are palatable with spicy foods.

8. Thinking beer is just fizzy and yellow

Wine enthusiasts I talk to sometimes are surprised to hear that beer is actually a more versatile pairing partner than wine. If you look at what beer is made of, you’ll see why: beer contains cooked flavors, floral and citrusy hop aromas and bitterness. All of these can be powerful tools for creating harmonies and managing contrasts. It’s also extremely varied in all of its characteristics: color, cooked flavors, bitterness, alcohol, acidity and more.

9. Taking the audience for granted

We all vary genetically and by physiological and psychological factors like age, health status, energy, interest and medications. Fortunately, these are rarely factors that affect pairings. Basic tastes and mouthfeel are mission-critical for the body, so they have very little variability, the one exception being bitterness. Fortunately this is not much of a player in food or wine, although it adds greatly to beer’s capabilities if you understand its power to balance fat or sweetness. 

Smell is a bogglingly complex system, resulting in a lot of person-to-person variability in our responses to odors. The good news is that the system is massively redundant. Most odors stimulate many different receptor types, most receptors responding to multiple chemicals. Even if some are a little insensitive, there are others that can still deliver a unique pattern of responses the brain uses to recognize odors. These patterns are discarded before they reach the brain, but not before being translated to meaning, value and context. This means your concept of a peach, for example, is shared with everyone with similar experiences, no matter the specific pattern of receptor responses. This shared reality depends on personal experience, which in turn is shaped by cultural context. 

Over our lifetime, each of us builds and maintains a library of congruent flavor associations. These are highly pleasant and harmonious. Things that are present together but not in our library are more likely to be perceived negatively. They take more effort by the brain to assess and if too extreme may be perceived as “clashing,” as one would say of a pairing.

If you’re trying to push an audience out of their comfort/familiarity zone, always do soin a context in which the novelty makes sense or else be prepared for trouble.

10. Making it a presentation rather than an interaction

So often, pairings feel performative and sometimes even intimidating. To me, they’re a lot more fun when you can bring the guests into the process and let them discover for themselves what works best. Remember that people are highly suggestible, so resist the urge to give them too much detail up front, and listen to what they have to say about it—you might learn something new. 

Language is so potent that it can steer the senses towards what is expected rather than what is actually being sensed. In these situations, they’re unsure of their own abilities and may be relieved to hand the task off to an authority figure, but don’t let them. 

Getting ahead of a pairing with a description of what the guests can expect is basically asking them to ignore their senses and focus only on what the “correct” interpretation of the pair is supposed to be. People need guidance, but they also need permission to go off-script and discover what works for themselves. So anyone guiding a pairing should be striving for balance between the two. Otherwise, participants will risk missing out on the surprises that their unique perspectives bring to the process.

I usually start by stating the three things that always need to be considered: making sure one thing doesn’t overwhelm the other, managing contrasting tastes and mouthfeel sensations and finding connections between aromas. Describing potentially salient aspects of the flavors in the food and drink is a stealthy way to suggest what they might look for, without limiting their options. 

Nothing’s more fun for me—and the guests—than when a tasting becomes fully interactive. The only roadblock is their reticence and fear of saying the wrong thing. In any pairing, the interactions are almost endless. If you can get an audience truly engaged, you’ll be amazed at how much they have to teach you!